The debate between Mercedes-Benz and BMW enthusiasts is as old as time, especially when discussing their iconic models from the past. A recent online forum discussion highlights this enduring rivalry, sparked by a car review perceived as favoring the Mercedes-Benz 190E over the BMW E30 M3.
One forum member, BMWPower06, voiced concerns about an apparent bias in a review, arguing for the E30 M3’s superior status and widespread desirability. However, another contributor offered a balanced perspective, suggesting the reviewer’s opinion might be more nuanced. This commenter pointed out the reviewer’s ownership of both an E30 M3 and a 190E, implying a deeper understanding beyond simple bias. They even referenced the reviewer’s critique of the 190E’s shifter, contrasting it sharply with the “God-like” feel of the E30’s. This suggests a more objective assessment was at play.
Furthermore, the discussion touched upon the driving experience of these classic machines. The second commenter, drawing from their own experience with a BMW 318is and a Mercedes-Benz 300E, acknowledged the BMW’s engine could be “rough and annoying” for daily driving, contrasting it with the thrill it provided on winding roads. This personal anecdote adds weight to the idea that different cars excel in different scenarios, and preferences are often subjective.
The notion of universal E30 M3 adoration was also challenged. While acknowledging the BMW’s popularity, the commenter countered that many Mercedes enthusiasts hold equal affection for the 190E. Sharing their past ownership of a 300E, they emphasized the excellence of these older Mercedes models, lamenting the loss of their own due to unforeseen circumstances. This personal touch underscores the lasting appeal and robust nature of the Mercedes 190E and its contemporaries.
In conclusion, the forum exchange reveals the passionate and often contrasting viewpoints within the classic car community. While the BMW E30 M3 undoubtedly holds a special place for many, the Mercedes-Benz 190E maintains its own dedicated fanbase, appreciated for its unique qualities and enduring legacy. The “better” car ultimately comes down to individual preferences and driving priorities, a point subtly highlighted in this online discussion.
