Choosing between a Lexus and a Mercedes-Benz can be a tough decision for any car enthusiast. Both brands represent luxury, quality, and prestige, but they cater to different preferences and offer distinct driving experiences. Let’s delve into a detailed comparison, drawing on insights from a seasoned automotive expert, to help you navigate the “Lexus Vs Benz” dilemma.
When considering long-term ownership and reliability, Lexus often takes the lead. While acknowledging that repairs on a Lexus can be expensive, the expert suggests that you are statistically more likely to encounter fewer problems compared to a Mercedes-Benz, particularly when looking at models from the same era, like the Lexus LS 400 and the Mercedes-Benz W124.
However, the Mercedes-Benz W124, a classic in its own right, presents a compelling argument when it comes to interior material quality. There’s a certain robust and premium feel to the W124’s interior that suggests no compromises were made in its construction. In contrast, some older Lexus models, after surpassing the 90,000-100,000 mile mark, can exhibit wear on leather surfaces. Despite this, Lexus vehicles generally hold up better in terms of electrical systems compared to some Mercedes-Benz models of similar vintage, which might face issues like biodegradable wiring harnesses.
Moving to the realm of comfort and convenience, Lexus shines with its thoughtful “creature comforts.” Lexus vehicles tend to be designed with user experience in mind, offering a range of features that enhance daily driving. The expert notes a surprising omission in the W124: the lack of a tilt steering wheel, offering only a telescoping function. Furthermore, features common in Lexus and Infiniti models, such as automatic steering wheel and seat retraction upon exiting the vehicle, are absent in the W124.
Noise, Vibration, and Harshness (NVH) levels are also areas where Lexus typically excels compared to the W124. Lexus vehicles are engineered for a serene and quiet cabin environment. Similarly, Lexus often integrates superior stereo systems compared to their Mercedes-Benz counterparts from the same period.
For navigating daily traffic, Lexus vehicles often provide a more relaxed and comfortable experience. This is attributed to softer seats, lighter accelerator pedals, enhanced ergonomics, and superior instrument illumination, moving away from the less powerful bulbs sometimes found in older Mercedes-Benz models. Specifically referencing the LS 400, the expert highlights the absence of engine wiring harness problems, a known issue in some older luxury cars. Drawing upon experience with Toyota’s broader product line, the expert also speculates that Lexus AC systems are likely more durable, contrasting anecdotes of costly AC evaporator replacements in other brands with the relative lack of such complaints among LS 400 owners. The LS 400’s air conditioning is also noted as being significantly more effective and responsive than the slower and sometimes temperamental AC system in the W124. The W124’s AC controls are described as less intuitive, potentially frustrating drivers with limited fan speed control in automatic mode, reflecting a more rigid, “old school” approach to engineering. Furthermore, the Lexus LS 400 transmission is praised for its smoother and more responsive shifting compared to the W124.
The Mercedes-Benz W124, in contrast to the modern and refined Lexus, embodies a more “old school” character. Sitting in both cars side-by-side reveals a distinct difference in philosophy and design approach. While acknowledging the Lexus LS 400 as a “good car,” the expert finds it lacks the personality and distinctive design of the W124, suggesting it can feel generic, almost like an “overgrown Toyota Camry.” The expert also points out the use of off-the-shelf Toyota parts in Lexus vehicles, viewing it as a potential “marketing mistake” that might detract from the perceived exclusivity of the brand. Aesthetically, the W124 is deemed more pleasing and possessing a timeless design that is likely to age more gracefully than the LS 400.
In conclusion, the “lexus vs benz” decision ultimately hinges on personal priorities. Lexus offers superior reliability, comfort, and a feature-rich experience, making it a pragmatic choice for those prioritizing hassle-free ownership and modern luxury. Mercedes-Benz, particularly the W124, appeals to those who value robust build quality, a more engaging driving experience, and a classic, timeless design with a stronger sense of personality. Both brands offer compelling vehicles, but cater to distinct preferences within the luxury car market.
