The opening credits of Dexter are undeniably captivating, setting a unique and unsettling tone for the series. Julie Benz, known for her role as Rita Bennett, Dexter’s girlfriend, wholeheartedly agrees, describing them as “brilliant” and “creepy,” perfectly encapsulating the essence of the show. This meticulous attention to detail extends to the overall visual aesthetic, thanks to director of photography Romeo Tirone, who masterfully captures a film-like quality in high definition.
While high definition can be unforgiving, revealing every detail, Benz embraces the honesty it brings to her portrayal of Rita. Far from seeking a glamorous depiction, she appreciates the genuine portrayal of her character. Interestingly, she jokes about still appearing “too pretty” on screen, even in more vulnerable scenes. She fondly recalls a shot in Season 1, watering a lemon tree, as surprisingly beautiful. This “warmth” isn’t accidental; producers intentionally ensure a sense of warmth in Rita’s scenes through lighting adjustments, contributing to the show’s distinctive visual style.
When asked about scenes exemplifying this “visual warmth” in Season 2, Benz candidly points to “any of the love scenes, the nude scenes.” She laughs, acknowledging the flattering portrayal, “Oh God, they make me look amazing, yes! They make me look beautiful.” This comfort with her appearance allows for a raw and authentic performance, where genuine emotions and expressions are visible, unmasked by artificial enhancements. Benz emphasizes the freedom in portraying Rita’s vulnerability, a stark contrast to her experiences on shows like Buffy the Vampire Slayer and Angel. While those WB shows offered glamorous on-screen “deaths” with false eyelashes and lip gloss, Dexter‘s Showtime platform allows for a more realistic and stripped-down portrayal, even if it invites audience comments on aging and appearance.
Benz connects deeply with Rita’s vulnerabilities and insecurities, seeing a reflection of a raw, exposed side of herself in the character. She describes the role as requiring her to be “open and relaxed and allow myself to be vulnerable.” Interestingly, playing Rita impacts Benz’s personal life, making her more emotional and prone to sighing.
Beyond her own scenes, Benz highlights the visually striking scenes between Dexter and Lyla in Season 2, particularly in the finale. The fiery scenes set by Lyla are especially memorable, conveying the Miami heat and heavy atmosphere palpably on screen. This visual storytelling is a crucial element of Dexter‘s immersive quality.
Regarding commentaries, Benz favors those from writers and creators, finding actor-led commentaries often devolve into jokes. She cites Sly Stallone’s Rocky Balboa commentary as an example of insightful commentary from a filmmaker deeply involved in the creative process, articulating his vision for every frame.
The interview touches upon the evolving relationship between Rita and Dexter, particularly after the dramatic events of Season 2. Benz believes Rita remains oblivious to Dexter’s dark secret, choosing to see only the good in him. Even with overwhelming evidence, Rita’s unwavering faith in Dexter would likely persist. This dynamic highlights Rita’s role in bringing out Dexter’s humanity, evident in scenes like him playing with Cody, showcasing a connection unlike any other in his life.
Looking ahead, Benz expresses a desire for Rita to have a fresh start in a new, cleaner house, contrasting with Rita’s less-than-perfect housekeeping skills. She humorously recalls Rita’s “badass” moment of stealing a noisy neighbor’s dog in Season 1, highlighting a rare instance of Rita’s unconventional behavior. Teasing Season 3, Benz mentions Jimmy Smits joining the cast and hints at “exciting” developments. Ultimately, Benz envisions a “happily ever after” for Rita and Dexter involving a normal, quiet life, perhaps with more children, a stark contrast to their past traumas and violence, emphasizing their shared desire for normalcy.
