)
At first glance, the Mercedes-Benz GLA might easily be mistaken for its hatchback sibling, the A-Class, and for good reason. It essentially elevates the hatchback formula, appealing to drivers who desire a smaller vehicle but with the sought-after characteristics of an SUV. While some GLA models boast roof bars, ostensibly for expedition gear, Mercedes-Benz understands their more likely purpose: roof boxes or snowboards for weekend getaways.
Similarly, the BMW X1 also presents itself as a raised hatchback, drawing heavily from the BMW 1 Series design language. The X1 proudly displays its lineage within the BMW SUV family, sharing distinct design cues with its larger counterparts, the X3 and X5. This familial resemblance is evident in its overall silhouette, the iconic BMW front grille, and its confident stance.
Driving Dynamics: How Do They Perform on the Road?
)
Unlike many traditional crossover SUVs, the BMW X1 distinguishes itself with impressive handling capabilities. Its lower ride height compared to typical SUVs contributes to this agility, but the true magic lies in BMW’s expertly engineered suspension system. This refined suspension translates to a remarkably composed driving experience, whether navigating winding country roads or enduring long motorway journeys. The X1 minimizes body roll, offering a more planted and controlled feel than taller, bulkier SUVs.
Available in petrol, diesel, and plug-in hybrid powertrains, the X1 consistently delivers brisk acceleration and responsive performance. This ensures ample power for confident motorway cruising and nimble maneuvering in urban environments.
The Mercedes-Benz GLA counters with its own set of driving virtues. It excels in urban driving scenarios, thanks to its raised suspension and light, effortless steering. The elevated seating position provides enhanced visibility over traffic, a significant advantage in congested city streets. Similar to the X1, the GLA offers a range of engine options, including turbocharged petrol, diesel, and plug-in hybrid variants, catering to diverse driver preferences.
Interior Cabin and Technology Features
)
Stepping into the Mercedes-Benz GLA reveals a cabin that embodies the premium ambiance synonymous with the Mercedes-Benz brand. A selection of four distinct trim levels allows for personalization, but even the base-level SE models are generously equipped. Standard features include air conditioning, a convenient reversing camera, refined leather trim, stylish 17-inch alloy wheels, and the added safety of automatic emergency braking. Ascending through the trim levels unlocks even more sophisticated technology, such as wireless smartphone charging, advanced LED headlights, front and rear parking sensors, and a larger, more immersive 10.25-inch touchscreen display.
However, the BMW X1’s interior is equally compelling, upholding BMW’s long-standing reputation for crafting functional and luxurious car interiors. The X1 prioritizes driver and passenger comfort with supportive seats, including lumbar support for enhanced back comfort on longer drives. BMW’s intuitive iDrive infotainment system is standard, offering seamless control over vehicle functions and entertainment. Audiophiles can further elevate the audio experience with the optional Harman/Kardon stereo system, boasting enhanced speakers and amplified power. Crucially, both the GLA and X1 come standard with Android Auto and Apple CarPlay integration, allowing drivers to seamlessly integrate their smartphones and access familiar apps and interfaces without navigating a new infotainment system entirely.
Cargo Capacity and Practicality Considerations
)
In terms of boot space and overall practicality, it’s important to approach both the GLA and X1 with the mindset of larger hatchbacks rather than full-fledged SUVs. Their compact dimensions inherently mean slightly less cargo capacity compared to larger SUV segments. The Mercedes-Benz GLA offers a respectable boot capacity of up to 495 litres. Slightly edging out the GLA, the BMW X1 provides a maximum boot volume of 500 litres.
To provide context, both boot capacities are more than sufficient for accommodating a substantial weekly grocery shop, a couple of large suitcases for airport runs, or a collection of soft bags for a weekend escape. Rear passenger space in both vehicles is generous in terms of headroom and legroom, offering more spaciousness than typical hatchbacks, though naturally less expansive than larger SUVs.
Safety and Reliability Ratings
Given their modern engineering and build quality, both the Mercedes-Benz GLA and BMW X1 inspire confidence in terms of long-term reliability. Benefitting from stringent German engineering standards and the utilization of shared components across their respective model ranges, both vehicles are expected to offer dependable performance with consistent and routine servicing. For added peace of mind, services like cinchCare can be considered to further extend vehicle longevity and provide additional protection.
In terms of safety, both the GLA and X1 have achieved the highest possible five-star rating in recent Euro NCAP crash tests. These top safety ratings underscore their robust construction and commitment to occupant protection in the event of a collision.
Dimensions and Size Comparison:
Mercedes-Benz GLA Dimensions:
Length: 4410mm
Width: 1834mm
Height: 1616mm
Boot space: 495 litres
BMW X1 Dimensions:
Length: 4500mm
Width: 1845mm
Height: 1642mm
Boot space: 500 litres
Final Verdict: BMW GLA vs X1 – Which Compact SUV Reigns Supreme?
Having explored this detailed comparison between the Mercedes-Benz GLA and BMW X1, you might already be leaning towards a preferred choice. However, to solidify your decision, here’s a concise verdict.
For drivers prioritizing a more pronounced SUV feel and aesthetic, the GLA is a compelling option. Its higher seating position and overall design language genuinely evoke the SUV experience, offering a commanding view of the road and surrounding traffic compared to a standard hatchback. Furthermore, the GLA is replete with advanced technology features, enhancing driving enjoyment and convenience, particularly on longer journeys.
Conversely, the BMW X1 is ideally tailored for driving enthusiasts who value dynamic handling and a more engaging driving experience. Its sharper handling dynamics and finely tuned suspension deliver a rewarding drive, whether tackling twisty country lanes or cruising on the motorway. The X1 strikes a balance between sporty responsiveness and everyday comfort, making it a versatile choice.
